Fire Island National Seashore Travel Guide

Discover the best places to visit, hike/bike routes, food and drink scene, where to stay, and more in Fire Island National Seashore.


Introduction to Fire Island National Seashore

Fire Island National Seashore is one of New York’s hidden gems located in Suffolk County. It is a 32-mile-long barrier island that is surrounded by white sandy beaches, sheer sand dunes, salt marshes, and dense maritime forests. It is home to several hard to reach spots, which allows for a memorable beach experience. This beautiful area is recognized as a national park and contains the Lighthouse Beach, a 19th century lighthouse, and several walking, hiking, and biking trails.

List of Places to Visit in Fire Island National Seashore

If you’re planning to explore this stunning area, be sure to check out the following places:

Culturally Important Attractions: Museums and Historical Places

  • Fire Island Lighthouse: This iconic lighthouse was built in 1826 and can be found on the western edge of the park. You can climb the lighthouse and enjoy the breathtaking view of the island.

  • Sailor’s Haven Visitor Center: If you’re interested in learning more about Fire Island National Seashore’s history and heritage, then this is a great place to visit. You’ll find exhibits, educational programs, and brochures which will help you learn more about the area.

Natural Attractions of Fire Island National Seashore: Outdoor Adventures and Scenic Views

  • Otis Pike Fire Island High Dune Wilderness: This is home to several trails that offer panoramic views of the island. This area has no permanent structures, roads or boardwalks. It’s a critical habitat for several species of reptiles, mammals, and birds.

  • Wilderness Visitor Center: Located in Smith Point County Park, this area offers kayaking, swimming, nature walks, and bird watching activities. You’ll also find exhibits here that offer in-depth information about wildlife habitats in the Fire Island region.

Hiking/Biking Routes of Fire Island National Seashore

Fire Island National Seashore has some of the best hiking and biking trails in New York. These are the top options to consider:

  • Fire Island Lighthouse Trail: This is a mile and a half with a round trip and offers scenic views of the ocean, dunes, and forest.

  • Sunken Forest Loop Trail: This is a two-mile-long trail that winds through the forest of Fire Island. It’s a great place to bird watch, and you can even catch stunning sunsets.

Best Things to Do in Fire Island National Seashore: Activities and Tours

There’s more to Fire Island National Seashore than just hiking and biking. Here are some other activities to explore:

  • Boat Tours: Join a boat tour of the island and see the more remote parts of Fire Island. You can also spot a variety of marine wildlife including whales, dolphins, and seals.

  • Fire Island Paddle: If you love kayaking, then Fire Island Paddle is a must-do activity. You can paddle in the Great South Bay and explore the serene environment filled with wildlife.

Week-Long Itinerary for Fire Island National Seashore

Day 1: Start with hiking the trails and taking in the stunning views at Fire Island Lighthouse.

Day 2: Relax and unwind at Otis Pike Fire Island High Dune Wilderness.

Day 3: Visit the Sailor’s Haven Visitor Center and learn more about the history of the island.

Day 4: Catch the stunning sunset at Sunken Forest Loop Trail.

Day 5: Take a boat tour or kayak trip to experience the island from a different perspective.

Day 6: Enjoy the food and drinks scene on the island; continue to Smith Point County Park and indulge yourself with a variety of dishes.

Day 7: Pack your bags and take the train from Sayville back to Manhattan while reminiscing about your incredible week in Fire Island.

Food and Drink Scene of Fire Island National Seashore

If you’re a food lover, then Fire Island National Seashore is the perfect place. Here are some must-try dishes:

Must-Try Dishes

  • Blueberry Pancakes at CJs Restaurant and Bar: This mouth-watering dish has a unique twist of adding fresh blueberries in pancake mix topped with a generous amount of whipped cream.

  • Lobster roll at Flynn’s restaurant and bar: This delightful seafood dish includes fresh lobster meat served on a perfectly toasted bun with fries on the side.

Local Beverages

  • Mango Margarita at Hideaway: This is a classic cocktail, but with a tropical twist of adding with fresh mangoes.

  • Fire Island Beer Company: This brewery has been a go-to destination for beer lovers since 2010. Their beers are a perfect mix of local flavors and traditional American styles.

Where to Stay in Fire Island National Seashore: Hotels, Hostels, and Guesthouses

There are several places to stay while exploring Fire Island National Seashore. These are some of the best options:

  • The Pines: This is a luxurious option for those who want to enjoy the natural beauty of the island. It offers a pool, gourmet dining, and a private beach.

  • Cherry Grove Hotel: This is a beautiful guesthouse located on the eastern side of the island. It has a tranquil ambiance and a stunning view of the ocean.

What to Buy in Fire Island National Seashore: Souvenirs and Local Products to Bring Home

If you’re looking for some authentic souvenirs to bring back home, then there are plenty of options here. These are some of the most popular items:

  • T-shirts and sweatshirts with Fire Island National Seashore logos.

  • Sea salt harvested from the Great South Bay.

Local Culture and Customs of Fire Island National Seashore

Fire Island National Seashore is a friendly and welcoming place. The locals are warm-hearted and exude a laid-back vibe. They believe in living life at a leisurely pace and take great pride in the natural beauty of the island.

Best Time to Visit Fire Island National Seashore

The best time to visit Fire Island National Seashore is from late May to early September. During these months, the weather is perfect for outdoor activities, and the island is alive with activity.

Do’s and Don’ts of Fire Island National Seashore

Do:

  • Respect the natural beauty and wildlife of the island.

  • Take a walk around the Fire Island Lighthouse to witness a stunning sunrise/sunset view.

Don’t:

  • Ignore life-saving rules and safety regulations.

  • Litter or damage the environmental resources of the island.

Safety and Health

Safety in Fire Island National Seashore

Fire Island National Seashore is a safe place, but visitors should take precautions. These are some tips for visitors:

  • Wear comfortable clothing and shoes appropriate for hiking, biking, or walking.

  • Carry a water bottle and extra snacks to avoid dehydration.

Health in Fire Island National Seashore

  • Carry insect repellent, especially during the summer months.

  • Avoid swimming in areas where signs indicate water quality risks.

Getting to Fire Island National Seashore: Transportation Options and Logistics

Getting to Fire Island National Seashore is easy. These are the options available to visitors:

Airports Near Fire Island National Seashore

  • John F. Kennedy International Airport is about 83 km away from Fire Island National Seashore.

  • Long Island MacArthur Airport is only 9 km away from Sayville, where ferries depart to the island.

Bus Stations Near Fire Island National Seashore

  • The Long Island Rail Road offers bus services from Penn Station to the Sayville Ferry Terminal.

Other Options

  • Take a ferry from Sayville Ferry Terminal to your preferred points on the island.

How to Get Around in Fire Island National Seashore

Fire Island National Seashore offers several transportation options to visitors. You can explore the island on foot, bike, or hire a golf car. However, be sure to respect the natural beauty of the island and its residents.

Where to Go Next from Fire Island National Seashore: Nearby Destinations and Excursions

Once you have explored Fire Island National Seashore, there are several other destinations nearby to visit. These are some great options:

  • The Hamptons: This area is known for its beautiful beaches and exquisite restaurants.

  • Montauk: Located in Long Island, this area is famous for its lighthouses, beaches, and natural beauty.

Conclusion

Fire Island National Seashore is a must-visit destination for outdoor enthusiasts, food lovers, and beachgoers alike. It offers stunning views, delicious food, and a wide range of activities to choose from. So, plan your visit today, and experience the magic of Fire Island National Seashore.

Fire Island National Seashore areas Fire Island National Seashore areas