Bay Shore Travel Guide

Discover the best places to visit, things to do, where to stay, what to eat and more in Bay Shore, New York, with this comprehensive travel guide.


Introduction to Bay Shore

Bay Shore, located in Suffolk County, Long Island, is a small seaside town with a population of approximately 27,000. The town’s name comes from the fact that it is located on the southern shore of the Great South Bay, which is one of the most popular water bodies in Long Island.

Bay Shore is known for its enchanting natural beauty, historic landmarks, and vibrant culture. The town is home to the Fire Island National Seashore, which has some of the most pristine sandy beaches in the east coast, and the Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, which is a beautiful botanical garden. Additionally, there is a plethora of restaurants, shops, and museums that offer a glimpse into the local culture.

Whether you’re a local or a first-time visitor, this comprehensive travel guide to Bay Shore will help you make the most of your time in this charming town.

List of Places to Visit in Bay Shore

Culturally Important Attractions: Museums and Historical Places

  • The Historical Society of the Greater Bay Shore Area: This museum features exhibits that showcase the history of Bay Shore and its neighboring towns, including early American artifacts, maps, and paintings.

  • Sagtikos Manor: This historic house museum dates back to the 18th century and was once the home of wealthy ship-owners. The estate has stunning gardens and is surrounded by more than 10 acres of land.

  • Captree State Park: This park is a popular spot for fishing and boating. There are several boat tours available, which offer stunning views of the Great South Bay and the Fire Island.

  • Oakdale-Bohemia Greenbelt Trail: This trail is perfect for hiking and biking. It consists of over 1500 acres of protected forest area, making it a vast green space and a great place to escape from the city’s hustle and bustle.

Natural Attractions of Bay Shore: Outdoor Adventures and Scenic Views

  • The Fire Island Lighthouse: This lighthouse, located on the western end of Fire Island, is one of the most iconic landmarks of Bay Shore. Visitors can climb up to the top of the lighthouse and enjoy the spectacular views of the ocean and surrounding areas.

  • The Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park: This park is a beautiful botanical garden that features rare plants, trees, and flowers. It also has several walking paths that offer stunning views of the bay.

  • Robert Moses State Park: This state park, located on the western end of Fire Island, is a popular spot for swimming, boating, and fishing. The park also has several picnic areas and hiking trails.

  • Sunken Meadow State Park: This park, located on the north shore of Long Island, is a popular spot for beachgoers. It has a two-mile-long sandy beach, hiking trails, and picnic areas.

Hiking/Biking Routes of Bay Shore

Bay Shore is home to several hiking and biking trails that are perfect for outdoor enthusiasts. Some of the popular trails include:

  • Robert Moses and Fire Island Lighthouse: This trail covers a distance of approximately six miles and offers stunning views of the ocean and surrounding areas.
  • Connetquot River State Park Preserve: This park has several hiking trails that cover a distance of over 50 miles. It is a great place to go hiking, biking, or birdwatching.
  • Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park: This park has several paths that are perfect for hiking and taking a leisurely stroll.

Best Things to Do in Bay Shore: Activities and Tours

  • Bay Shore Wellness Alliance: This wellness center offers yoga classes, acupuncture, and massage therapies in a peaceful environment.
  • Bay Shore Bikes: This bike rental store offers bikes and electric bikes for rent, giving visitors an opportunity to explore the beautiful Bay Shore on their own.
  • Great South Bay Brewery: This brewery is a great place to enjoy some locally brewed beer. It offers tours and tastings on weekends.
  • Tiki Island Mini Golf: This miniature golf course is perfect for families. It is beautifully landscaped and has several water features.

Week-Long Itinerary for Bay Shore

Day 1: Visit the Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, which is one of the most beautiful botanical gardens in Long Island.

Day 2: Go hiking on the Robert Moses and Fire Island Lighthouse trail, which offers stunning views of the ocean and surrounding areas.

Day 3: Take a boat tour of the Great South Bay, which offers unparalleled views of the Fire Island National Seashore and the surrounding areas.

Day 4: Visit the Sagtikos Manor, which is a historic house museum with beautiful gardens and a sprawling estate.

Day 5: Take a bike tour of Bay Shore with Bay Shore Bikes and explore the town’s beautiful scenic spots.

Day 6: Visit one of the local breweries, such as the Great South Bay Brewery. Enjoy some locally brewed beer and learn about the brewing process.

Day 7: Head to the Fire Island Lighthouse and climb up to the top to enjoy the beautiful views of the ocean and the surrounding areas.

Food and Drink Scene of Bay Shore

Bay Shore has a vibrant food and drink scene that offers a range of cuisines from all over the world.

Must-Try Dishes

  • Lobster Roll: This classic New England dish is available in several local restaurants and seafood shacks in Bay Shore.
  • Clam Chowder: This thick soup made of clams, potatoes, and cream is a must-try dish in Bay Shore.

Local Beverages

  • Blue Point Brewing Company: This brewery is located in Patchogue, just a few miles away from Bay Shore, and offers a range of locally brewed beers.
  • Del Fuego: This Mexican restaurant in Bay Shore has an impressive range of margaritas, mojitos, and tequila shots.

Where to Stay in Bay Shore: Hotels, Hostels, and Guesthouses

Bay Shore has several accommodation options, including hotels, motels, and guesthouses. Some of the popular options include:

  • Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island: This hotel offers comfortable rooms at an affordable price and is located close to many local attractions.
  • The Fox & Owl Inn: This guesthouse is perfect for travelers who prefer a more personal touch. It is beautifully decorated and has several amenities to make guests feel at home.

What to Buy in Bay Shore: Souvenirs and Local Products to Bring Home

Bay Shore has several local shops and boutiques that offer unique souvenirs and local products. Some of the popular items to buy include:

  • Island Strong: This shop sells clothing and accessories that are inspired by Long Island’s culture and heritage.
  • Bay Shore Soap Company: This local store offers handmade soaps that are made from natural ingredients and are perfect for gifting.

Local Culture and Customs of Bay Shore

Bay Shore has a rich culture that is steeped in history and tradition. The town’s maritime past is reflected in its architecture and landmarks. The local community is friendly and welcoming, and visitors are sure to have a great time exploring the town’s unique culture.

Best Time to Visit Bay Shore

The best time to visit Bay Shore is between May and September when the weather is warm and pleasant. The summer months are ideal for outdoor activities and exploring the town’s beautiful beaches.

Do’s and Don’ts of Bay Shore

Do:

  • Explore the local culture and heritage by visiting museums and historical landmarks.
  • Enjoy the beautiful natural scenery by going hiking, biking, or walking along the beach.
  • Try the local cuisine, including seafood, clam chowder, and lobster roll.

Don’t:

  • Litter or damage the natural surroundings.
  • Disrupt the local community or cultural events.
  • Engage in unsafe activities or put yourself or others in danger.

Safety and Health

Safety in Bay Shore

Bay Shore is a safe town with friendly locals and low crime rates. Visitors should take normal precautions to stay safe, such as locking their cars and not leaving valuables unattended.

Health in Bay Shore

Bay Shore has several healthcare providers, including hospitals and clinics. Visitors should have comprehensive travel health insurance to avoid any financial burden in case of emergencies.

Getting to Bay Shore: Transportation Options and Logistics

Bay Shore is easily accessible by car and public transportation.

Airports Near Bay Shore

  • John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)
  • LaGuardia Airport (LGA)
  • MacArthur Airport (ISP)

Bus Stations Near Bay Shore

  • Bay Shore Bus Terminal (located in the center of town)
  • Suffolk County Bus Service (provides service to other parts of Long Island)

Other Options

  • Taxis, Uber, and Lyft are available for hire.

How to Get Around in Bay Shore

Bay Shore is a walkable town with a well-connected public transportation system. Visitors can take buses or rent bikes to explore the town’s attractions.

Where to Go Next from Bay Shore: Nearby Destinations and Excursions

Bay Shore is located close to several other towns and cities that are worth exploring, including:

  • Montauk: A beach town located at the eastern end of Long Island, known for its beautiful lighthouse and sandy beaches.
  • New York City: The largest city in the United States, located just a few hours away from Bay Shore, and home to some of the world’s best museums, galleries, and restaurants.
  • The Hamptons: This affluent area of Long Island is filled with luxury homes, high-end shops, and restaurants, and is a great place to go for a weekend getaway.

Conclusion

Bay Shore is a charming town filled with opportunities for outdoor adventures, cultural experiences, and relaxation. With this comprehensive travel guide, visitors can explore the town’s hidden gems and create memories that will last a lifetime.

Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church Sagtikos Manor Sagtikos Manor Bay Shore Hose Company No. 1 Firehouse Bay Shore Hose Company No. 1 Firehouse